Taleb's Barbell Strategy #84
Market Meditations | January 26, 2021
Limited downside and (potentially) unlimited upside
In today’s FREE letter, we explore Nassim Taleb’s Barbell Strategy.
A portfolio allocation method for traders and investors, that allows you to limit your downside and maintain (potentially) unlimited upside ?
If you enjoyed this article, remember to share it with your network. Let’s all grow richer together.
Harvard, Yale and Brown University Buying Bitcoin for at Least a Year ?
Some of the largest university endowment funds in the U.S. have been quietly buying cryptocurrency for the past year or so through accounts held at Coinbase and other exchanges, CoinDesk has learned. According to 2 sources familiar with the situation, Harvard, Yale, Brown and the University of Michigan as well as several other colleges have been buying crypto directly on exchanges. Read more.
Treasury Moves Forward With Stalled Crypto Monitoring Rule ?
With Yellen confirmed, The U.S. Treasury Department’s now-infamous proposal to require information on crypto transfers from exchanges to self-hosted wallets is back in motion. Per a Tuesday announcement from FinCEN, stakeholders will have another 60 days to respond to the proposal. While a marked improvement from the 15-day comment period of the original proposal, unfortunately for the crypto industry, it doesn’t look like the actual terms of the proposal have changed along with the administration. Read more.
Grayscale Adds $2.4 Billion Worth of Crypto in Three Days ?
According to a tweet published by Grayscale on Jan. 25, the company added $2.6 billion in crypto to its cryptocurrency holdings, going from $24.2 billion (on Jan. 22) to $26.6 billion in a record three days. The amount of the flagship cryptocurrency, Bitcoin, held by the largest crypto hedge fund, a subsidiary of Barry Silbert’s Digital Currency Group, has now surged to $21.7 billion—the largest share of crypto held by the company, compared to other digital assets. Read more.
Jihan Wu Writes That He’s Officially Stepping Down as Bitmain Chairman ?
Jihan Wu has officially announced his exit from Bitmain in a coded letter as part of an effort to settle a year-long internal power struggle. Wu’s rival co-founder Micree Zhan bought shares from other founding shareholders for a value of $600 million. The official settlement plan is also in line with previous reports that Bitmain is spinning off its mining businesses to streamline its model for an IPO. Read more.
A Digital Rupee Token May Be a Reality, Says Indian Central Bank ?
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI), the country’s central bank, has expressed an interest in introducing a digital version of the rupee. The central bank further said that it is examining the need and viability of a central bank digital currency (CBDC). India joins a notable list of nations that have expressed considerable interest in a CBDC, such as it’s neighbour, China. Read more.
Barbell Portfolio Allocation
In a previous letter, we covered the key takeaways from Nassim Taleb’s (@nntaleb) ? The Black Swan. In a sentence, we explored how low probability, high impact events can have a huge implication on traders and investors.
In today’s letter, we take a look at another Taleb book. This time: Antifragile: Things That Gain From Disorder. Specifically, we investigate his ‘Barbell Strategy’ as a portfolio allocation method.
This topic was inspired by the responses to our ✏️ thread, where we asked the Market Meditations community what their portfolio allocation strategy was.
It is worth noting that this strategy served Taleb particularly well during the 2008 Global Financial Crisis. He thrived while many fellow traders and investors went bankrupt. We always enjoy watching Taleb interviews, if you too enjoy the one below, you can also check out his iconic ? Commencement Speech ?
Traditional Theory of Portfolio Allocation
Many traditional theories of portfolio allocation are based on the thesis of risk tolerance, which is usually linked to age. For instance, this is the theory explored in Malkiel’s A Random Walk Down Wall Street.
Risk tolerance determines the proportion of low, medium and high risk investments an individual makes. Examples of each:
Low risk = government bonds and bank certificates of deposit
Medium risk = blue chip stocks
High risk = speculative stocks such as initial public offerings (IPOs), cryptocurrencies or small biotechnology companies
The young investor might put 40% in speculative stocks (high risk), 40% in blue-chip stocks (medium risk) and just 20% in government bonds (low risk).
On the other end of the spectrum, the old retiree might keep 80% in bonds (low risk) and 20% in blue-chip stocks (medium risk).
? Followers of Taleb’s barbell strategy would argue that the middle of the risk spectrum should be ignored altogether.
Barbell Theory of Portfolio Allocation
Taleb argues that an effective risk-taking strategy should strive to be ‘antifragile’: fully protected from total ruin while being exposed to the occasional unlimited upside.
From this, he forms what is called the barbell strategy. You can imagine a physical barbell.
A real life barbell has weights on each end and a bar in the middle to connect them.
With an investing barbell, on one side you have a small proportion of investments that are high risk but have high reward potential.
On the other side, you have a larger proportion of investments that are low risk and low reward potential.
No investments are held in the middle, or in other words, nothing medium risk or “average” is held in the portfolio. As Taleb puts it:
“I initially used the image of the barbell to describe a dual attitude of playing it safe in some areas and taking a lot of small risks in others, hence achieving antifragility. That is extreme risk aversion on one side and extreme risk loving on the other, rather than just the “medium” or the beastly “moderate” risk attitude that in fact is a sucker game (because medium risks can be subjected to huge measurement errors). But the barbell also results, because of its construction, in the reduction of downside risk — the elimination of the risk of ruin.”
Eliminating the Risk of Ruin
When it comes to portfolio allocation, Taleb believed that a lot of professionals misunderstood how to make profits over the long run. They believe that the focus should always be on coming up with bets that make them a lot of money.
? But what’s most important is something different. The difference appears minor but it is not. What’s most important is NOT to lose money.
A large proportion of low risk, safe investments has the critical benefit of protecting investors from the risk of ruin. As we have written many times, when it comes to trading and investing, survival is key. It’s not just us and Taleb who think so. Warren Buffett famously said:
“The first rule of investing is: never lose money. The second rule of investing is: never forget rule number one.”
And if you don’t take Buffett’s word for it, consider Ray Dalio’s advice:
“Make sure that the probability of the unacceptable (going bust) is nil.”
In a barbell strategy, the large chunk of investments are in hyperconservative investments thus eliminating the risk of ruin.
The Unbalanced Middle
The middle is unbalanced due to the risk reward trade off. Being in the middle gives you risk and limitations, while you’re not even exposed to the maximum upside.
What’s more, the occurrence of ‘Black Swan’ events means that the risk is incomputable. Sometimes, there are particularly special and rare events that leave such a profound impact that move markets in a severe and unpredictable way. We categorize these events as “Black Swan” events.
“Someone with 100 percent in so-called “medium” risk securities has a risk of total ruin from the miscomputation of risks. This barbell technique remedies the problem that risks of rare events are incomputable and fragile to estimation error; here the financial barbell has a maximum known loss.”
?Being in the middle gives the illusion of safety, but it’s actually the worst of both worlds: you’re still exposed to being wiped out by a black swan, while also having no opportunity to tap into the colossal gains that can swirl out of the same chaos.
In a recent CNN interview ?, Anthony Scaramucci noted how if you had a dollar, and kept 99 cents in cash and the other penny in bitcoin, over 10 years, it would have outperformed putting the dollar in the S&P 500. You can consider the S&P 500 to be the medium risk example here, with bitcoin being the high risk and cash the low risk. His comment is an indirect affirmation of the barbell strategy.
Maintaining Exposure to Large Potential Upside
A small proportion of your portfolio in hyper-aggressive investments maintains exposure to large potential upside. High risk investments have the potential to get you obscene wins, sometimes even greater than 100x return. Taleb refers to these events as positive Black Swans and uses the convex function to illustrate the nature of positive Black Swan occurrences.
? The key: taking some big risks to have a chance at the big wins whilst protecting yourself from total ruin. Taleb eloquently sums this up with a simple balance of 90/10:
“If you put 90 percent of your funds in boring cash (assuming you are protected from inflation) or something called a “numeraire repository of value,” and 10 percent in very risky, maximally risky, securities, you cannot possibly lose more than 10 percent, while you are exposed to massive upside.
An example would be 90% of your net worth in a cash savings account with the other 10% in cryptocurrency, say Bitcoin. The worst that could happen? Bitcoin goes to zero and you lose 10% of your net worth. You have capped your downside. The best that could happen? Your Bitcoin bet could return 1000%.
The numbers are guidelines, not rules. But the point remains:
1️⃣Protect yourself from total ruin
2️⃣Avoid the unbalanced middle
3️⃣Go for a few high risk high reward bets
“For antifragility is the combination of aggressiveness plus paranoia — clip your downside, protect yourself from extreme harm, and let the upside, the positive Black Swans, take care of itself…
And there we have it, Taleb’s Barbell Strategy. Extremely risk averse on the one side and extremely risk loving on the other, generally avoiding the middle. Which decreases the chances of risk of ruin while potentially increasing upside with very speculative but small bets. How you set your portfolio allocation strategy is down to you and your own preferences. All we aim to do at Market Meditations is share with you some of the best resources we have come across in the wealth of literature around trading and investing. We provide the tools and then you build whatever it is that suits you.
? We’re here to build richer lives for our readers. That includes more articles like this, that include wealth building strategies from some of the greatest minds in the world, broken down in a concise and easily digestible format. Join our free community today to unlock your access to the full range of insights and analysis ?
Want More Meditations?
? FREE Educational Resources:
? Join the AK Community:
? More Market Meditations:
Disclaimer: The content in this newsletter is for informational purposes only. Nothing in this email is intended to serve as financial advice. I am not a financial advisor. Every investment and trading move involves risk. Do your own research when making a decision.